INTO THE DARKNESS by Laura Castellano Wow. I never thought I'd be posting another X-Files story. What can I say? I'd like to be able to thank Mary, my usual beta reader, for her excellent commentary on this story, but instead I must offer her my apologies. Mary, I would have loved to have you beta, but I know how you love a happy ending, and I just couldn't bring myself to inflict this one on you. RATING: If you can handle "hell," "damn" and angst, you should be ok. ARCHIVE: Yes DISCLAIMER: Not mine, never were, never will be. SUMMARY: Light or dark. Life or death. Good or evil. All of life is made up of choices, and we have to live with every choice we make. Mulder knew, when he picked up the gun that morning, he was facing his destiny. KEYWORDS: Angst. More angst. Still more angst. TIMELINE: Now read this, because this is important. This story begins with the events of Anasazi, and branches off into a totally different storyline. There's a DAT tape, but there's no boxcar, no fire, no Blessing Way, no murder of Melissa, etc. I hope you enjoy it. WARNING! THIS IS NOT A HAPPY, FLUFFY STORY! Neither Mulder nor Scully dies, but this piece is not MSR. "Fox? I need you to come here. Now. Tonight." Mulder fingered the sharp outline of the DAT tape inside the pocket of his leather jacket. He'd barely returned to his apartment before the sound of the ringing phone had startled him. "This really isn't a good time, Dad. I'm in the middle--" "*Now*, Fox." The senior Mulder's voice was colored with urgency and something else--fear? Mulder wasn't certain of that, but he was absolutely sure he'd never heard his father sound this way before. The realization spurred him to action. "I'll be there as soon as I can." Mulder put down the phone without saying goodbye, and stared at it for a long moment. He knew he was followed on a regular basis, but he'd been so careful tonight. Was it really possible that they already knew he had the tape? If that was the case, then The Thinker was a dead man. If not already, very soon now, and Mulder had no way of warning him. Cursing under his breath, Mulder hurried to his car. He wondered, briefly, if he should call Scully, but decided this wasn't the best time to bring her into it. If his suspicions were correct, he just might be walking directly into a trap. He didn't believe his father would willingly put him in danger, but they could be using him, as well. Anything was possible with these people. The last thing Mulder wanted was to have Scully taken away again. The thought of her so near death still made him break down inside, although so far he'd managed to keep that secret carefully to himself. The gulf of emptiness he had experienced at almost losing her had shocked him. Up until that time, he knew he cared for her; he had not known he was in love with her. The drive to West Tisbury should have taken him around seven hours, but Mulder made it in just over five. He hopped the ferry to the Vinyard, then had to cool his heels for another interminable hour. By the time he reached the Vinyard, dawn had already broken. The air was chill, and Mulder inhaled the aromas of his childhood. Fish, salt, excitement. This was the Vinyard Mulder tried to remember. This was the way it had been, up until the time Sam had disappeared. The times after that...well, he didn't care to reflect on them too deeply. He didn't even have time to knock before his father opened the door and ushered him quickly into the house, glancing around the street before closing the door behind them. "Do you still have it?" he demanded without preamble. "Have what?" Bill Mulder sighed, and grasped his son by both arms. "Fox, if you still have the tape, tell me now. Everything depends upon it." Mulder intended to lie, but the truth spilled out as soon as he opened his mouth, and his father seemed pleased to hear it. "I have it." His father's lips twisted into what could have been a wicked smile. "Good. Hold onto it. When you reach your destination, put it somewhere safe, somewhere it can never be discovered. It could save your life one day, if they ever find you." Mulder frowned, shaking his head slightly. "Dad, what are you talking about? I'm not going anywhere. Don't you understand? I finally have the proof I need to bring them down! I'm not going to run away, like some--" "Yes, you are!" The ferocity in his father's voice took Mulder aback. "I don't know what you're talking about." "What you don't know is who you're dealing with. What they're capable of. Oh, you think you know," he forestalled, seeing Mulder about to speak. "You think you've seen the worst they can do. Let me tell you, son, you haven't even scratched the surface of their capabilities!" Mulder snorted. "What can they do? Kill me?" "Not just you." That gave Mulder pause. "Scully?" "They control her now, Fox." "No!" Mulder denied angrily. "No one controls her. Scully would never betray me!" "I don't mean of her own free will. I mean," he said, leaning in closer for emphasis, "they can *control* her. They can do to her anything they want. You've gone too far this time." Mulder searched his father's eyes, still confused, and the elder man sighed. He released his son and slumped wearily to the sofa. "I used to be a powerful man in this organization. There was a time when my word was law. Then, someone else managed to edge me out. He took control, and from that moment on, we were doomed." "We?" He was ignored. "When they took your partner, they did things to her. Horrible things. Things you can't begin to imagine. I haven't time to go into detail. The only thing you need to know is that they control her. Whether she stays lucid or sane, healthy or ill, whether she lives or dies, is all in your hands now. She'll be protected, but only if they think she can't possibly be a threat to them. Even after you're gone, they'll be watching her. You can never contact her. You can never come back, Fox. Ever." Leaving Scully forever. Such a thought had never occurred to him, even in his worst moments. He felt the tape inside his pocket once more, felt the promise its smooth plastic casing held, and knew he'd give it all up just to go back to yesterday. "Here," he said, pulling it from his pocket and holding it out. "They can have it. Give it back to them. Call it an even trade--Scully's safety for their damn tape." His father suddenly looked sad, and very, very old. "I'm afraid it doesn't work that way." "Well why not? They want their tape back, they can have it. I haven't had a chance to even find out what's on it yet. I'll just...have to find the truth another way." "It's too late, Fox. You can't just cry 'no harm, no foul' at this point." He fixed Mulder with a steady, pointed stare. "They have to believe you're dead." "Dead!" "I've already taken care of the details." He reached into a drawer in the table beside the sofa, and withdrew a small packet. "This is your new identity. It is imperative that you are not followed, so be more careful than you've ever been in your life. We have about a fifty-fifty chance of pulling this off, but neither of us has anything to lose. If we don't try, you die. And so does Scully." "So I'm a dead man either way, is that what you're telling me?" "You begin to understand." "Dad, I can't just--" "Go, Fox. Go now. You haven't any time to lose. I'll handle things here. Leave your car. Give me your wallet. The evidence will prove that you died here tonight, for anyone who doesn't look too closely." "And if they do?" "I'll see to it they don't." Mulder was about to argue, but was finally convinced by the tears that filled his father's eyes, and the words choked out around them. "Trust me, Fox. You're my son. Trust me." "All right, Dad. I'm trusting you." He reached out to shake his father's hand, but was pulled into an unexpected embrace. For a single moment, the security and emotion of his childhood, and yes, even the comforting scent of his father's clothing, permeated with the smell of the cigarettes Bill Mulder loved, reached him. In the next moment it was gone, and he was left with nothing but the memory of the void that had filled his life for years after Sam had disappeared. Pulling away from his father's arms, Mulder slipped out the back door and disappeared into the night. ***** "Did he agree?" "He did. Did you do your part?" Krycek nodded. "In the car." "How did you accomplish it?" The younger man smiled. "Don't worry. It isn't traceable." "Bring him in. You have work to do here before dawn." Krycek was good, the elder Mulder had to give him that. If any insomniac neighbors happened to be watching, they never would have guessed that the bundle brought into the house over Krycek's shoulder contained a dead body. It could have been a rug, or a large amount of dry-cleaning, or any number of other things, but the last thing it resembled was a well-wrapped corpse. "Over there," he said, pointing to a spot on the floor. Krycek positioned the body as directed. When all was arranged to satisfaction, Bill nodded. He seated himself again on the sofa. "You brought the things I requested?" "Of course." "Get them." "What exactly is it you want me to do, Mr. Mulder?" Bill looked around the room for a moment, then sighed heavily. "I want you to destroy this room and everything in it." "But--" "Just do it. Quickly." Nodding his head, Krycek went to retrieve his supplies. ***** Scully heard the telephone ringing as she emerged from the shower. She raced for it, catching it just before the machine would have picked up. "Scully." "Agent Scully, it's Assistant Director Skinner." She snapped to attention at once. "Yes?" There was something odd in Skinner's voice. "Sir, is everything all right?" "Scully, I...don't know how to tell you this." A tremor, that's what it was. Skinner sounded shaken. "Just tell me, Sir." "Mulder...last night..." Scully gripped the phone harder, her heartbeat quickening. "Is Mulder all right?" Skinner cleared his throat, and she could picture him straightening, pulling himself into his usual, dignified persona. "Agent Scully, I regret to inform you that late last night, there was an explosion at the home of Mulder's father. Two bodies were discovered this morning, both burned almost beyond recognition, but it's believed--" "Sir, please don't tell me--" "It's believed the bodies are those of Agent Mulder and his father." Scully sat down on the bed slowly, her knees weakening, and let the phone slide from her hand. She ignored the repeated inquiries of her boss, diminishing from her awareness as she took in what he had said. Mulder. Mulder was gone. ***** There was money in the packet his father had given him. Not a lot, but it would do for a while. He'd have to find some sort of work, and a place to live. Most importantly, he'd have to find a way to contact Scully and let her know he was alive. There was no way he was going to leave her to grieve for him when it could be avoided. His father had been rushed, he'd been forced to make plans quickly. He hadn't had time to think the entire situation through. Mulder, on the other hand, had ridden a bus all night, with nothing to do *except* think. He wasn't certain how it was to be accomplished yet, but there had to be a way to communicate with her safely. By the time dawn broke, he'd reached a small, backwater town in Connecticut. It seemed as good a place as any to stop for a rest, and he was exhausted. He checked into a nondescript motel using his new identity, and breathed a sigh of relief when the clerk didn't bat an eye at his bogus driver's license. Mulder paid cash for two nights, went to his room, and fell onto the bed without even undressing. After a while, he got up, showered, and crawled into bed naked. He'd have to buy some new clothes soon, and a toothbrush. Everything, in fact. He'd left his father's house, ridden the ferry to the mainland, and boarded a bus almost immediately. He had no possessions to his name except a little money and a fake ID. And the DAT tape. Insurance, his father had said. In case they ever found him. The finality of that idea overwhelmed him, and Mulder was surprised to find himself awash in pure despair. How had this happened? He couldn't allow himself to wallow in self-pity for long, however. He hadn't gone far enough. He'd sleep all day, then board another bus, to make his way farther west. Farther away from Scully, and all that he loved. Burying his face in the pillow, he tried to sleep. ***** He awoke when the late afternoon sun crept through the crack where the curtains met and splashed across his eyes. Shielding them from the glare, Mulder looked over at the clock. Just after five. He was starving. He'd spotted a McDonald's a couple of blocks away early that morning, so after pulling on his clothes, Mulder eased out the door. He examined the parking lot closely, then the surrounding businesses. If someone had followed him, they were doing an excellent job of remaining hidden. At last deciding that if they came for him, there wasn't a lot he could do, Mulder pulled the door closed and set off. He wished he had a car, so he could at least visit the drive-through window. There was more anonymity that way. It couldn't be helped, he told himself, but he needn't have worried. A busload of hungry tourists had converged on the restaurant in search of sustenance, and the frazzled employees were too busy filling orders and making change to even look at their customers. Mulder took his food and hurried back to what he felt was the relative safety of his motel room. He reached for the remote, flipping through the channels until he found an evening newscast, and dug into his burger. A few minutes later, he stopped with a fry halfway to his mouth as his own name blared from the television. "An explosion and fire rocked a quiet neighborhood in West Tisbury, Massachusetts last night as a house erupted into flames. Firemen were able to contain the blaze, which was suspected to have been caused by a ruptured gas line. Two badly burned bodies were discovered in the house. Police have not yet made positive identification, but they are believed to be the bodies of the homeowner and his adult son. Authorities say more information should soon be forthcoming. And in other news..." Food forgotten, Mulder simply sat staring at the television with his mouth open for a few seconds. "Dad!" he whispered. "Oh, no..." Had this been his father's plan all along? To kill himself while faking his son's death? Or had Bill Mulder faked his own death as well? Was he still out there somewhere, riding a bus, sleeping in motels, much like his son? It was a nice idea, but somewhere inside himself, Mulder knew it wasn't true. He'd seen the lines of weariness on his father's face the night before. Bill Mulder may not have actively sought out suicide, but when the opportunity arose, he'd taken it willingly. Then the thought occurred that perhaps it hadn't been willing. His father had insisted he would handle all the details, but he couldn't have done it alone. Could someone have been working with him? Someone who had agreed to help his father eradicate Mulder's own life, and taken the opportunity to eliminate William Mulder as well? If that was the case, then someone out there knew he was alive. Who? Mulder looked around the darkening room uneasily. Suddenly, the feeling of relative safety he'd convinced himself was genuine seemed very, very tenuous. It was time to move on. ***** It was amusing, how much Mulder's friends thought they knew about the government, he mused as he listened. They considered themselves paranoid in the extreme, wise to every trick, up to date on every new gadget. On the other hand, he had to admit, they really couldn't be blamed for their magnified perception of their own worth. After all, he had technology at his fingertips that they couldn't begin to visualize. With it, he'd been able to watch and listen as they first grieved, then questioned, then began to search. They believed Mulder was out there, alive somewhere. He agreed. They believed it was only a matter of time before they found Mulder. He agreed with that, too. They believed that when they did locate their friend, they could somehow help him out of his predicament. On this, he was forced to part company with them. There was nothing they could do to help. Fox Mulder was dead, and for his own safety, he must remain so. If he should surface, he would find himself in a situation where death would become a blessing. The explosion and fire that had taken the life of Bill Mulder and an unidentified man resembling Bill's son had satisfied his colleagues. It had not satisfied him. He knew William Mulder, perhaps better than any of them. Certainly he'd known how the man's mind worked better than the others. Bill was disillusioned and disgusted with the turn their work had taken, and it was believable that he would sacrifice himself. What was beyond acceptance was the idea that he would sacrifice his own son. Even Mulder's mother believed her son had died that night. He had seen her grief, and it had moved him, as much as he allowed anything to move him, but he kept his own counsel. The results of the tests he'd privately had run on the body had proven to him beyond a doubt that Fox Mulder had not died in that fire, but since for all intents and purposes he had, it was best to let Teena do her grieving alone. After determining Mulder was, in fact, still very much alive--or at least that he hadn't died in Bill Mulder's house the night of the explosion--he had tapped into his best resource: Mulder's friends. He'd been certain they would eventually lead him to Mulder, and they had done so. Now he had to move, before they actually contacted Mulder. ***** The blond man with the slightly darker goatee looked up at his next customer and froze. Hazel eyes, turned slightly greener by contact lenses, dilated. He felt the adrenalin rushing through his system, and tried to decide whether to run or fight. Bluffing was out of the question; there was no way this man's appearance could be a coincidence. "Hello, ah...Frank," the man said, reading Mulder's name tag. "I would like some assistance, if you please. Over here." He beckoned to the farthest corner of the men's clothing department and waited for Mulder to precede him there. Mulder did, finally, because the chance of being murdered was only slightly less onerous than the knowledge that he'd have to come to work here in this department store, day after day, for many years to come. The boredom had sapped him of any enthusiasm he might have retained for life already, even after only a few months. "Are you here to kill me? Go ahead. Do your worst," he invited softly. The answering chuckle was equally soft. "Indeed, no. I don't believe for a moment that the tape was destroyed in the fire. I believe you still have it, and I know you would have made some arrangement for it to come to light in the event of your death. That cannot be allowed to happen." "How did you find me?" "Your friends are very enterprising." Mulder's eyebrows rose, and the man smiled again. "Don't be concerned. They know nothing of me, or of the fact that I've been listening to them for months. If they should be so ill-advised as to contact you, I trust you have the good judgement to redirect them." "Why are you here?" "Have you translated the tape?" "What tape?" "Please, Fox. The time for deflection is long past. Have you?" Mulder shrugged. "A little. It took me a while to figure out that it was written in ancient Navajo. I've had to study up on it myself. It isn't an easy language to learn." "There are secrets there that you might be happier not knowing." "What difference can that make now?" "I need reassurance, Fox. You and I both know that you would care little for your own life, if you could expose the information contained on that tape. You're like your father in that manner." "Did you have him killed?" "I did not. Bill Mulder arranged that explosion himself. He had an accomplice. We believe we know who, but finding the man has proven difficult." "Krycek?" "I see you've figured things out on your own." "I've been working in a mind-numbingly boring job for the past few months. I haven't had much to do except think. It wasn't a great leap of logic to figure out. You still haven't told me why you're here." "Actually, I came to offer you a deal. I had hoped you were still ignorant of the contents of the tape. Since you aren't..." he shrugged, "the deal will have to be altered." Mulder glanced around, spotted a couple of customers approaching, and called to a co-worker. "Ryan, I'm going on break. See to those guys, will you?" He pulled the man through a door leading to a corridor and led him to the employee break-room, now mercifully empty. "What are you talking about, old man?" he demanded. "And make it quick, because I only have fifteen minutes." "It's very simple, Fox. Unfortunately, your curiosity has, so to speak, killed the cat. If you had left the tape alone, I was prepared to offer you a chance to return to your old life in exchange for it. However, things have changed. It's far too dangerous for you to come back now. Still, there is a deal to be made, if you're interested." "What kind of deal? I've seen the tape. I'm slowly translating it. I can't go back to being ignorant." "You give me the tape, and I give you Scully." The words, bluntly spoken, hit Mulder in the gut like a well-placed punch. "You--you have Scully?" he managed, white-faced, barely able to muster the breath to speak. ***** It was all going his way. This felt wonderful. Ignoring the 'No Smoking' sign on the wall, the man reached into his pocket, withdrew a pack of cigarettes, shook one out, lit it, took a good long drag...all the while allowing Mulder to writhe inwardly. When he felt he'd tortured the young man enough, he smiled again. "No." Mulder visibly relaxed, and the smoking man knew his prize was won. Mulder still had feelings for Scully. He would hardly be able to turn down the deal he was about to be offered. "However, I can attempt to reunite you. A trade. You give me the tape, and I will arrange a "death" for Scully. She can join you." He paused a beat. "You won't have to be alone any longer." ***** Scully at his side again. Her smile, the glint of her hair, the complexity of her personality that both challenged and fit with his all at the same time--her presence. He had almost convinced himself he'd purged the desire for her, but now it came back in full force, and he was forced to admit it had never really gone. And yet-- "Have you talked to Scully?" "No." "Then how do you know she'd come?" The smoker took another long pull on his cigarette, then tamped it out in an empty coffee cup someone had left behind. "It's up to you to convince her. I'll arrange a time when it will be safe for you to meet with her. Someone will contact you, receive the tape from you, and tell you when you may visit Scully without danger." "How can I trust you?" "You must make that decision on your own. If something goes wrong, you're a dead man, and Scully...well, she proved quite useful to us in the past. We have no current plans to revisit her, but I'm sure an exception could be made, if it was decided you should be punished. This is a dangerous game you've chosen to play, Fox. But you knew that from the beginning, and you willingly brought Scully along for the ride." Mulder digested this, wanted to deny it, and finally had to admit that what the smoking man said was true. He had kept Scully at his side, out of selfishness and jealousy, it could be argued. But not entirely, he amended--even when they were separated, she had wanted to be working with him. No, he hadn't kept her at his side. She had remained, of her own volition. Would she come with him now, using that same freedom of choice? He could only ask. "Fine," he agreed at last, feeling weary to his marrow. "When can I expect your messenger?" "Soon. Be prepared." With that cryptic message, the smoking man left him. Mulder felt only dejection and fear. What the hell was he getting them into now? ***** It was accomplished quickly, the very next day, and Mulder was thankful he'd retrieved the DAT tape from its hiding place as soon as he'd left work after the smoker's visit. A knock at the door of his small apartment, an unobtrusive messenger--("You have a tape for me, Sir?")--and a piece of paper thrust into his hand containing a date, time and location. Two days hence, ten p.m. Sunday night. At her apartment. Now the appointed time had arrived, and he was nervous. Very nervous. Mulder sat in the rental car he'd parked down the block from her building, watching the rain coat his windshield and trying to convince himself to go to her. He couldn't imagine what her reaction would be. He'd tried to picture it a thousand times over the past two days, and still hadn't been able to predict how Scully would react, not only to finding him alive, but to his invitation to leave her home, her work, her family and come away with him, to live a strange life undercover in another town with another name. To never see her mother again. All at once, his proposal seemed garish and obscene. Could he possibly ask it of her? He knew she cared for him--at least she had before he'd "died"--but how did she feel now? Had she managed to grieve and move on? Would he be a welcome revelation, or an intrusion into a life she'd built for herself without him? There was nothing to do but ask. What he'd told his father all those months ago still held true: he knew Scully would never betray him. If she said no...well, he'd just fade back into the woodwork from which he'd emerged. Then, he might consider putting a bullet in his brain, but that was a decision for another day. He placed his feet purposefully on the sidewalk, one step after another, forcing himself to cover the distance between his car and her apartment. He didn't have an umbrella, but he barely noticed the raindrops falling. The familiar walk transported him to happier days, and by the time he reached her front door, he had begun to believe there was a chance she might agree. He raised his hand to knock, but laughter drifting from an open window stopped him. Standing there alone, his arm still poised, Mulder listened. "But really, Melissa, I'm all right." "You're better now," the voice of Scully's sister answered. "I was worried about you for a while, Dana." "I know." Scully paused, and when she continued, he heard a definite wistfulness in her voice. "I really liked working with Mulder, most of the time. It was exciting." "But...?" "But I don't miss the danger involved. And you know, Gary's nice, too. He does tend to go by the book more than Mulder did, but that can be a relief sometimes. I like my assignment with him." "You still think of Mulder often, though, don't you?" "Of course I do. We went through a lot together. I'll never forget him. But Melissa, he was such a--I don't know, I guess what I'm trying to say is that Mulder was such a tortured person, he's probably happier where he is." "Well I'm glad to see you moving on." "I have, Missy. I really have." Mulder didn't wait for more. He would often wonder, in years to come, if he had done the right thing. What if he'd knocked on her door that night? What if Scully had seen him, thrown her arms around him, and agreed to follow him anywhere? What if she'd turned him down? Rising to face another day as Frank Melman, of Rosstown, Arizona, Mulder shook away the thoughts. Even the promise of suicide he'd made to himself, he hadn't been able to keep. When it came right down to the wire, Mulder had decided he couldn't follow through. Light or dark. Life or death. Good or evil. All of life is made up of choices, and we have to live with every choice we make. Mulder knew, when he picked up the gun that morning, he was facing his destiny. Light or darkness. What hurt, what really made him want to hang his head and just cry sometimes, was the certainty that of the two, he had not chosen light. END Visit my stories at: http://laurita.freewebpage.org/index.html Feedback is welcomed at: laurita_castellano@yahoo.com